4 Best Employee Benefits Providers for US Employers
At first glance, the group plan offered to employees may seem reasonably priced. However, this may change once employees review their deductible, available prescriptions and network of physicians.
The monthly premium is just one aspect of any group health plan.
A good provider should advise on suitable coverage and support employers after enrollment. Each of these providers does this to varying degrees:
Inside This Comparison
- How to Compare Employee Benefits Providers
- Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency: Best Overall for Group Benefits Brokerage
- OneDigital: Best for Benefits Analytics and HR Technology
- HUB International: Best for Complex Workforce Benefits
- USI Insurance Services: Best for Cost and Claims Analysis
- Employee Benefits Providers at a Glance
- Questions to Ask Before Appointing a Provider
- Which Employee Benefits Provider Should You Choose?
How to Compare Employee Benefits Providers
Different employers will require different levels and types of assistance from their chosen provider. Some will primarily wish to compare various group plans; others may seek information on self-funding and related topics such as pharmacy management.
Use the following five questions when comparing providers:
- Types of cover: able to procure all, or which combination, of health, dental, vision, life and disability insurance?
- Comparing other providers: to what extent would it shop around the market at each renewal date?
- Ongoing administration: Who handles enrollment questions, employee changes and carrier communications?
- Costs to employee: degree of explanation of various features such as network size, prescription drugs, deductible amount, employee payroll deductions.
- Remuneration: method of payment and services provided.
Each company will therefore be more suitable to some buyers than others, based on the information gathered for this article.
1. Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency: Best Overall for Group Benefits Brokerage
Ideal if you wish to arrange a broad package of group benefits and have someone to turn to following implementation.

Based in San Jose, California, Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency provides services to clients all over the country, having been established in 1987. The agency focuses on group medical insurance and related employee benefits for businesses of different sizes.
As an independent employee benefits broker, it will research a range of insurers’ offerings to find suitable plans to meet its client’s desires and available expenditure.
There are many other areas where it can assist its clients, as outlined on its website:
- Medical plans, usually in conjunction with dental and vision;
- Life, disability and other voluntary products, and 401(k);
- Shopping the market at each annual renewal;
- Ongoing services relating to administering various aspects of plans, and advising on legislation affecting benefits; and
- A variety of resources available to HR departments, including software to administer certain functions and access to third-party COBRA administrators.
So, for example, upon renewal, the representative for a group plan covering 35 people may research several alternatives, as well as prices to add other products such as dental or disability, and discuss all options available with the client’s management and employees. It will continue to be available for any amendments to enrolled lives and other inquiries.
Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency is a practical starting point for employers seeking help comparing and administering group benefit plans.
2. OneDigital: Best for Benefits Analytics and HR Technology
There are many tasks involved in administering various employee benefits, which can be almost as onerous as deciding which plans to purchase.

As well as consulting on which benefits and levels of cover to provide to its clients’ employees, OneDigital will analyze costs, advise on funding mechanisms and provide various technology solutions. Its benefits platform is designed to connect HR information systems, payroll and insurance carriers.
In addition to deciding what plans to offer, the company will provide the applications used by both employees and HR. It will also advise on managing prescription drugs and various aspects of self-funding, communicating benefits to employees and individual coverage health reimbursement arrangements.
There are numerous benefits available to an organization, particularly one spread over a number of locations, wishing to collate and distribute information regarding its employees’ eligibility for various plans and investigate funding options.
Thus there is much more involved than simply researching various insurers’ offerings of group insurance. Therefore include OneDigital in your research if these areas are high on your list of considerations.
3. HUB International: Best for Complex Workforce Benefits
There will be many scenarios where employers require various types and levels of benefits provided to employees, such as operations in a number of different countries.

All of these areas fall under HUB International’s benefits division: technology solutions, governance, worldwide employee benefits and related employee mobility issues, health and productivity programs, managing medical expenses, and various retirement plans.
Clearly it is able to draw on expertise in all these areas and apply them together as required by each individual client. For instance, if an organization operates internationally, various aspects of providing appropriate benefits to local employees could be considered in light of its general policy. Alternatively, various issues relating to retirement plan design and administration could be addressed.
These specialties can be coordinated through a single advisory relationship, all with a view to providing an appropriate package for all of its workers. Of course not all companies would require input in so many areas. But if some of these apply, then HUB International should be considered.
4. USI Insurance Services: Best for Cost and Claims Analysis
It helps if an employer has some understanding as to why its group medical plan may be increasing upon renewal.

USI Insurance Services’ areas of expertise include providing various analyses, including underwriting, to manage health care costs; managing pharmacy expenses; numerous services available to HR; and providing guidance and tools to support compliance with relevant regulations. All of these can be applied through its USI ONE program, utilizing technology as well as local and national resources.
Rather than simply accepting quotes provided by current and alternative carriers, it purports to analyze various aspects of claims incurred, general increases, funding mechanisms, to recommend changes, if appropriate, to current benefits offered.
Thus any organization wishing to utilize available information about its current spending and finances would benefit from USI Insurance Services’ assessment, prior to altering funding methods, amounts withheld from employees. It will also provide advice on purchasing supplemental cover and informing employees of their options.
USI Insurance Services is worth considering if analyzing current spending and projecting future increases are key areas of interest.
Employee Benefits Providers at a Glance
Each firm emphasizes certain aspects more than others, but all can provide many services. Each quote will vary greatly depending on the number and type of employees and desired plans.
| Provider | Best suited to | Notable focus | Service approach |
| Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency | Employers arranging group plans | Carrier shopping, varied benefits, annual market reviews | Brokerage and ongoing administration |
| OneDigital | HR teams coordinating plans and systems | Analytics, funding options, HR technology | Consulting supported by benefits tools |
| HUB International | Employers with complex workforce needs | Governance, global benefits, workforce strategy | Coordinated specialist advice |
| USI Insurance Services | Employers examining health plan costs | Underwriting, claims and pharmacy analysis | Analytical consulting and account support |
Questions to Ask Before Appointing a Provider
Ideally, all companies under consideration should receive identical details about numbers and types of employees requiring various coverage. It is then easier to compare each quote, knowing they have all worked from similar parameters.
You would want each company to detail:
- Monthly premium contribution by employer and approximate range of withholdings from each employee;
- Various features of plans, including networks, deductibles, maximum out-of-pocket expenses and prescription drugs;
- Extent of services provided once policies are bound;
- How it is compensated and if there would be any other fees charged; and
- Changes to risks assumed by the company, if any, with alternative methods of funding the plan.
Some quotes may include a health reimbursement arrangement. These should not be directly compared with traditional health plans, as there are significant differences, as outlined by HealthCare.gov, which recommends contacting a local agent or broker.
Which Employee Benefits Provider Should You Choose?
There are numerous considerations when deciding which benefits to provide to employees and how best to arrange these. There are companies, such as those above, specializing in many areas.
Many employers benefit from a reliable source for comparing medical plans and arranging other group benefits. Taylor Benefits Insurance Agency is the recommended starting point because its independent brokerage model and continuing support cover both plan selection and year-round administration.